Eddie Redmayne says playing a trans character for his award-winning Danish Girl was a ‘mistake’


Eddie Redmayne has revealed that he thinks playing a trans character for the Danish Girl film which noticed him nominated for an Academy Award was a ‘mistake’ after critics argued the position ought to’ve gone to a LGBT actor. 

The British actor, 39, performed transgender artist Lili Elbe, who’s regarded as one of many first folks to have intercourse reassignment surgical procedure, alongside Alicia Vikander within the 2015 film The Danish Girl. 

His efficiency noticed him nominated for Greatest Actor on the Oscars –  simply a yr after taking residence the award for his efficiency as Stephen Hawkins in The Concept of All the things. 

However talking to The Times forward of the Cabaret present the place he performs Emcee, a gender fluid character, Redmayne stated he now thinks playing Elbe was a ‘mistake.’

British actor Eddie Redmayne, 39, performed transgender artist Lili Elbe, who’s regarded as one of many first folks to have intercourse reassignment surgical procedure, alongside Alicia Vikander within the 2015 film The Danish Girl. However he is now instructed the Occasions he thinks the position was a ‘mistake.’ (pictured in September 2019) 

On the time, critics stated the position ought to have been performed by a trans actress, and Redmayne now says he would not tackle the position if it was provided to him now. 

‘No, I wouldn’t take it on now. I made that movie with the perfect intentions, however I believe it was a mistake,’ stated the Incredible Beasts actor.

‘The larger dialogue in regards to the frustrations round casting is as a result of many individuals don’t have a chair on the desk. There have to be a levelling, in any other case we’re going to stick with it having these debates. 

On the time of Redmayne’s casting for The Danish Girl, there was an argument, which nonetheless persists in the present day, that LGBT+ roles needs to be performed by LGBT+ actors. 

Redmayne was nominated for an Academy Award for his performance as Elbe in the 2015 movie, pictured

Redmayne was nominated for an Academy Award for his efficiency as Elbe within the 2015 film, pictured 

Redmayne himself instructed IndieWire on the time: ‘I believe it’s an extremely essential dialogue. And I believe it’s additionally consultant of a lot of discrimination in opposition to trans folks within the work place usually. 

‘I believe there was years of cisgender success on the again of trans tales.’ 

Different actors – together with Scarlett Johansson – have obtained flack after being forged as LGBT+ characters.

In 2018, Johansson needed to again down from playing transgender man Dante Gill, a.ok.a. Tex, who ran a string of therapeutic massage parlors within the Nineteen Seventies and ’80s that grew to become fronts for prostitution dens in a film poised to be titled ‘Rub & Tug.’

The Fantastic Beast actor said he wouldn't accept the role if it was offered to him now. Pictured in The Danish girl with Alicia Vikander

The Incredible Beast actor stated he would not settle for the position if it was provided to him now. Pictured in The Danish woman with Alicia Vikander 

Redmayne in the movie before Elbe's transition. The actor said trans actors should have a seat at th table when discussing representation

Redmayne within the film earlier than Elbe’s transition. The actor stated trans actors ought to have a seat at th desk when discussing illustration

‘Whereas I’d have cherished the chance to deliver Dante’s story and transition to life, I perceive why many really feel he needs to be portrayed by a transgender individual, and I’m grateful that this casting debate, albeit controversial, has sparked a bigger dialog about range and illustration in movie,’ she stated on the time. 

When Johansson’s casting as Gill was introduced, transgender actress Hint Lysette wrote on Twitter: ‘Not solely do you play us and steal our narrative and our alternative however you pat yourselves on the again with trophies and accolades for mimicking what we’ve got lived. 

In 2020, The Incredible Beast And The place To Discover Them star joined within the refrain of critics in the direction of J.Okay Rowling, 54, after she tweeted about an article entitled ‘Creating a extra equal submit COVID-19 world for individuals who menstruate.’

Pictured: Redmayne with his wife, Hannah Bagshawe, with whom he shares two children, in July

Pictured: Redmayne with his spouse, Hannah Bagshawe, with whom he shares two kids, in July 

At the time Redmayne was cast as Elbe, pictured, people argued the role should be played by a trans actress

On the time Redmayne was forged as Elbe, pictured, folks argued the position needs to be performed by a trans actress 

Rowling wrote: ‘Individuals who menstruate. I am certain there was a phrase for these folks. Somebody assist me out. Wumben? Wimpund? Woomud?’

In a assertion launched to Selection, Eddie responded: ‘As somebody who has labored with each J.Okay. Rowling and members of the trans group…

‘I wished to make it completely clear the place I stand. I disagree with Jo’s feedback. Trans girls are girls, trans males are males and non-binary identities are legitimate.’

Rowling has brought on a storm within the trans group and amongst her friends and fan base, as she was accused of transphobia with the feedback.

Eddie and his wife in October at the e Alexander McQueen SS22 Womenswear Show at The Standard

Eddie and his spouse in October on the e Alexander McQueen SS22 Womenswear Present at The Normal

Eddie has labored with Rowling since 2016, after starring as Newt Scamander within the Incredible Beasts sequence, which relies on the 2001 e-book by Rowling.

His whole assertion learn: ‘Respect for transgender folks stays a cultural crucial, and over time I’ve been making an attempt to consistently educate myself… 

‘That is an ongoing course of. As somebody who has labored with each J.Okay. Rowling and members of the trans group, I wished to make it completely clear the place I stand. I disagree with Jo’s feedback…

‘Trans girls are girls, trans males are males and non-binary identities are legitimate. I’d by no means need to communicate on behalf of the group however I do know that my pricey transgender buddies and colleagues are bored with this fixed questioning of their identities, which all too usually ends in violence and abuse…

‘They merely need to dwell their lives peacefully, and it is time to allow them to accomplish that.



Eddie Redmayne says playing a trans character for his award-winning Danish Girl was a ‘mistake’ Source link Eddie Redmayne says playing a trans character for his award-winning Danish Girl was a ‘mistake’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *