Monday, September 20, 2021
HomeEntertainmentThe Tokyo Olympics need more politics, not less

The Tokyo Olympics need more politics, not less

Heading into the Tokyo Olympics, the phrase on most everybody’s lips was “controversy.”

From protests in Japan towards holding the Video games within the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic to questionable — and arguably racist and sexist — selections by the governing our bodies of a number of Olympic sports activities concerning hashish use, accredited competitors attire and extra, no current Olympics have begun underneath as darkish a cloud as these.

As we close to the occasion’s midway mark, although, the drama to date has been largely stored to the pool, the courtroom and particularly the gymnastics enviornment, with Simone Biles’ exit from the ladies’s workforce and particular person all-around gymnastics competitions dominating the headlines. Has the unpredictability of sport eclipsed the potential for controversy that marked the lead-up to Tokyo? Or is media coverage of the Olympics, particularly from U.S. TV rights-holder NBC, viewing the occasion by means of rose-colored glasses?

Occasions TV editor Matt Brennan, senior author Greg Braxton and employees author Tracy Brown, who’ve been preserving an in depth eye on the Video games from house, talk about the strain between Olympic spectacle and Olympic actuality:

Tracy Brown, employees author: With the rising variety of confirmed COVID instances and the low vaccination price in Japan, I used to be already fairly cautious in regards to the Tokyo Olympics within the weeks main as much as the opening ceremony.

Then got here headline after headline of assorted sports activities companies seemingly failing their athletes — notably ladies — beginning with sprinter Sha’Carri Richardson’s disqualification from the Olympic observe workforce for an archaic rule banning marijuana (a substance that’s authorized in lots of states). Nearly instantly after got here the information that the usage of swim caps designed for Black natural hair wouldn’t be allowed on the Video games. Then the story in regards to the Spanish Olympian who needed to leave her breastfeeding child at house.

Among the many most surprising is the report about a fencer accused of sexual assault who nonetheless traveled to Tokyo as an alternate on Crew U.S.A., towards the protests of his teammates, with a “security plan” that needed to be created to maintain him away from ladies. (And that’s not even entering into the controversies across the composer and the director of the opening ceremony, who each got here underneath hearth for previous problematic habits mere days earlier than the occasion, or any Tokyo protests.)

However as soon as the competitions have been formally underway, the TV broadcasts have kind of felt just like the Olympics as normal. The tales we get on TV have primarily been about highlighting particular person athletes and their achievements, with acquainted produced packages about their journeys to sit-down interviews following occasions. And even with the time distinction and difficulties in navigating learn how to watch these Video games, it’s been very simple to get caught up within the drama of the sports activities — from inspirational 13-year-old skateboarding phenoms and different history-making winners of occasions that I immediately care about as a result of it’s the Olympics, to the heartbreaking upsets.

I’ve watched a lot of the Video games reside on-line or as full occasions on NBC-affiliated cable stations slightly than the flagship’s prime-time block, so a lot of the reminders of the actual world exterior the Olympic bubble have come within the type of passing feedback or the pictures of individuals carrying masks, the empty stands and the occasional long-distance high-fives. And I perceive that these athletes deserve the highlight as they’re striving to attain their once-in-a-lifetime desires. However as somebody plugged into the information I can’t assist however really feel like there’s a massive disconnect between what we’re seeing on TV and the fact of the whole lot exterior the bubble. How has the expertise been for you each?

U.S. swimmer Caeleb Dressel celebrates after profitable the lads’s 100m freestyle ultimate on the Tokyo Olympics.

(Robert Gauthier/Los Angeles Occasions)

Matt Brennan, TV editor: At the least in the course of the day, when the lion’s share of my consideration is dedicated to the tales we’re publishing, I’ve needed to watch the Olympics primarily by way of Twitter, which solely amplifies the disconnect you describe, Tracy. Alongside celebrations of Hmong American gold medalist Sunisa Lee, as an illustration, — who topped gymnastics’ all-around podium about 14 hours earlier than it aired, on tape delay, in U.S. prime time — you may encounter updates in regards to the Delta variant, the Jan. 6 fee, the looming finish of the eviction moratorium and an infinite array of different information gadgets that break the Olympic spell. And no less than for me, that makes it more durable to relish the genuinely feel-good moments, like U.S. swimmer Caeleb Dressel becoming emotional about his separation from his household throughout “a very powerful yr” coaching for the Video games.

A part of the issue is the unusual place of any community televising the Olympics. Is it leisure? Sports activities? Information? The entire above? Because the Washington Publish’s Paul Farhi reported this week, NBC, like CBS earlier than it, has devoted many extra minutes to the Video games throughout its information broadcasts than its rivals, and so long as I can bear in mind has approached the Olympics with a type of boosterism that feels more and more out of step with the occasion’s popularity.

At the least since Salt Lake Metropolis in 2002, the Worldwide Olympic Committee — and the leaders of native bids — have been underneath some degree of scrutiny as to how the Video games are awarded, and the sense that the Olympics imply immense funding however paltry reward for host cities has solely deepened lately. (L.A. itself is a seat of Olympic skepticism heading into 2028.) It frankly feels ickier now to be rah-rah in regards to the Olympics than it was once, and the telecasts of Olympic occasions not often even nods at these qualms, a lot much less discover them intimately.

Which brings me to 1 final thought. We acquired an outpouring of responses to our final roundtable, most of them echoing our complaints in regards to the viewing expertise, and one throughline I’ve observed in these responses, in addition to my conversations across the (digital) newsroom, is nostalgia. I believe what we’re craving for, in sports activities, leisure and past, is the type of late-Nineteen Nineties, early-2000s monocultural second after we might all be speaking about the identical factor on the similar time. It’s one thing I wrote about when Michael Jordan docuseries “The Last Dance” premiered, however I sense that the craving has solely intensified within the final year-plus, as anti-maskers and anti-vaxxers, QAnon believers, election fraud hucksters, cable information hosts and others have proven the fragmentation to be much more dire. For a very long time, the Olympics bucked the development, however I believe Tokyo might be remembered as its swan tune.

Simone Biles with the Olympic rings behind her

Simone Biles watches gymnasts carry out after exiting the workforce ultimate Tuesday.

(Related Press)

Greg Braxton, senior author: I discover the query of what the Olympics is really fascinating and sophisticated. However one elephant that has been within the room and largely ignored by the protection is the darkish facet of racism surrounding these Video games — a darkish facet which may be inseparable from the stunning early lack of Naomi Osaka and the beautiful withdrawal of Simone Biles.

Each are phenomenal athletes. Each are activists who’ve proven solidarity with Black Lives Matter. And each have come underneath assault by conservatives infuriated by “wokeness” in sports activities. The pile-on was effervescent even previous to Osaka lighting the Olympic torch due to the persevering with racially charged musings of Megyn Kelly, and reached a type of fever pitch after Simone pulled out. It was straight-up bullying, and whereas colour was not talked about, it was clearly within the coronary heart of the attackers. I doubt if any elite white athlete who did what Simone did would have are available for that diploma of nastiness. And I really feel that could be a reputable information improvement that has been glossed over by the tv protection. That’s unlucky.

Even when we grant the need to maintain the power of Olympic protection optimistic, extra could possibly be finished to usher in real-world context. There was a possibility throughout Suni’s triumph Thursday, as an illustration, to level out its significance throughout a time in our nation when anti-Asian hate has spiked to terrifying extremes. However as soon as once more, there appeared to be no actual effort to make that connection, regardless that there are dozens of NBC personnel who might have finished so.

It’s very encouraging that there was such overwhelming help from seasoned athletes and others for Biles’ bravery. And to see her enthusiastically cheering on her teammates regardless of no matter private battles she is dealing with strikes me deeply. However the Olympics, particularly this yr, don’t happen in a bubble. The actual world exists, and there needs to be extra of an effort to have fun the achievements of athletes of colour and what impression their achievements may have on not simply illustration in sports activities, but additionally tradition and even politics. For all of the proof that the Olympic viewers is in decline, it stays the most-watched occasion on TV in the mean time, and thus an opportunity to carry tales about overcoming systemic racism and rising victorious to members of the viewers who might not in any other case encounter them. However much more emphasis must be placed on highlighting these tales to make a dent.

Simply mentioning this level is sure to make those that are racist, or really feel that there’s an excessive amount of give attention to the significance of variety, rush to their keyboards and hearth off vile remarks. Save your power, people. I understand how you are feeling — and I don’t have the urge for food to maintain hitting the delete button.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Most Popular